The Seven Best Books of 2023 Reviewed by Our Experts


By Leighan M Renaud, Andrew Dix, Dominic Broomfield-McHugh, Florian Stadtler, Jane O’Connor, Madeleine S. Killacky, and Simon Potter

We have covered a lot of new releases this year but these seven really impressed our experts. There’s a feminist retelling of a classic, a twist on the murder mystery from the greatest voice in horror and a giggle-inducing ride through the Middle Ages – not mention one of the most hotly anticipated autobiographies of all time.

1. The Fraud by Zadie Smith

Zadie Smith’s latest novel, The Fraud, is her first foray into the world of historical fiction. The result is a stunning, well-studied examination of Victorian colonial England and some of its inhabitants.

As with other works by Smith, the novel takes a patchwork approach, with several interwoven plots taking place over a period of about 50 years. Centrally placed in the plot is the real-life and highly bizarre trial of a man claiming to be a Sir Roger Tichborne, thought to have been killed at sea and heir to a substantial fortune.

The absurd and very long trial, which had people from all communities in 1870s England hooked, is seen in the novel through the eyes of Eliza Touchet, cousin and companion of William Ainsworth, a novelist well known in Victorian England but relatively forgotten today.

By Leighan M. Renaud, Lecturer in Caribbean Literatures and Cultures

2. Holly by Stephen King

At the age of 76, with nearly 70 novels and short story collections behind him, American author Stephen King shows few signs of slowing down. His latest novel Holly, hefty in scale and elaborate in plotting, is the work of an energetic writer, not one who is getting tired.

The book is a compelling composite of the crime and horror genres, as addictive as the cigarettes which the title character finds herself smoking, as she investigates a spate of abductions in a midwest town.

One of the incidental pleasures offered by Holly is its allusion to books from earlier in King’s long literary career. The terrifying incarceration experienced by the novel’s victims, for example, recalls that of the central figure in Misery (1987). A reference to blood poured over a high school prom queen summons up thoughts of Carrie (1974), King’s first novel.

That said, this new book shows King experimenting and innovating, rather than simply being content to reactivate the tropes of his previous fiction.

By Andrew Dix, Senior Lecturer in American Literature and Film

3.Julia by Sandra Newman

Given the relatively cardboard cut-out nature of the original character in Nineteen Eighty-Four, the foregrounding of [Julia’s] sexual experiences and sexuality as well as her early life gives her a vitality in this retelling lacking in Orwell’s portrait.

This is not so surprising. Orwell’s female characters (even Dorothy Hare, the eponymous heroine of A Clergyman’s Daughter, 1935) tend to be slight figures. By contrast, Newman’s Julia Worthing is anchored and adventurous. She’s willing to take risks and to suffer for her actions in ways that might seem unlikely if not impossible with Orwell’s Julia.

By Simon Potter, Professor of Modern History and Peter Marks, Emeritus Professor in English and Writing

4. Victory City by Salman Rushdie

Victory City is an epic chronicle of the rise and fall of Vijayanagar (the capital city of the historic southern Indian Vijayanagara empire), which acquires the name “Bisnaga” through ill-fated attempts at pronunciation by a Portuguese traveller … Throughout the novel, Rushdie explores the process of writing history – how it is recorded and how significance is apportioned. As Pampa Kampana states: “History is the consequence not only of people’s actions but also their forgetfulness.”

Rushdie is interested in how history is argued over and rewritten in contemporary moments. In particular, he takes aim at the populist exploitation of historical narratives for political gain. We hear that “fictions could be as powerful as histories” and that – paradoxically – “they were no more than make believe but they created truth”.

By Florian Stadtler, Lecturer in Literature and Migration

5. The Woman in Me by Britney Spears

Britney Spears’ new memoir, The Woman in Me, illustrates once again the potential lifelong damage that can be caused by being a child star. Like many before her, including Judy Garland and Michael Jackson, Spears was ushered into the dangerous terrain of childhood fame by the adults who were supposed to be protecting her, and was utterly unprepared to deal with the fallout.

Spears’ father’s conservatorship, controlling every aspect of her personal and professional life, was finally rescinded in 2021. She is now able to share the details of her extraordinary years in the limelight and beyond.

By Jane O’Connor, Reader in Childhood Studies

6. My Name is Barbra by Barbra Streisand

As a diva, Streisand has consistently defied instructions not to do something by doubling up her efforts. For example, at the start of her career when she was auditioning for record labels, one of the executives said she had a nice voice but was “too ethnic”.

Her response was to loudly embrace her Jewish identity. She played explicitly Jewish characters in her first two and only stage roles, in the musicals I Can Get It for You Wholesale (1962) and Funny Girl (1964). She refused to get a nose job and drew attention to her nose a lot in her work. And she co-wrote, produced, directed and appeared in the hit film Yentl (1983), about a Jewish woman who pretends to be a man in order to get an education.

Success has often come to Streisand by doing things people have told her not to do: a twist on the negative diva trope.

By Dominic Broomfield-McHugh, Professor of Musicology

7. Weird Medieval Guys by Olivia Swarthout

Packed full of satire, stunning imagery and interactive maps and quizzes, Weird Medieval Guys is a deep-dive into some of the most extraordinary – and quirky – aspects of medieval daily life. This little book, which should appeal to older children as well as adults, is split into two parts: The Struggle: Surviving Life, Love, and Death, and The Bestiary.

Weird Medieval Guys is a riot, packed full of brilliant medieval facts. Its author, Olivia Swarthout, has been creative in using quizzes and puzzles to engage readers who might like history but don’t get on with dense scholarly texts in the wonderful, wacky world that is the Middle Ages.

What is particularly evident to me as an expert in medieval literature, is the number of hours she has spent consulting digitised manuscripts from the first century onwards, as well as old and recent scholarship on medieval manuscript culture and life in general.

By Madeleine S Killacky, PhD Candidate in Medieval Literature

This article was originally published in The Conversation on 20 December 2023. It can be accessed here:

About the Authors

Leighan M RenaudLeighan M Renaud research focuses on contemporary Anglophone Caribbean literature. She is primarily interested in how contemporary writers from the region engage with themes such as gender, family, neo-coloniality, legacies of slavery, and language.

Andrew DixAndrew Dix is a Senior Lecturer in American Literature and Film, Loughborough University.


Dominic Broomfield-McHughDominic Broomfield-McHugh is a Professor in Musicology with a particular research interest in the Broadway, West End and Hollywood musical. 

Florian StadtlerFlorian Stadtler his main research interests lie in colonial and postcolonial literatures and film, especially South Asian writing in English and the work of Salman Rushdie, British South Asian history, literature and film, Indian popular cinema and its representation in South Asian fiction.

Jane O’ConnorJane O’Connor is a Reader in Childhood Studies at Birmingham City University. She is the author ofThe Cultural Significance of the Child Star(Routledge, 2008) and co-editor ofChildhood and Celebrity(Routledge, 2017). Jane has written extensively in the areas of representations of childhood and children’s engagement with media and digital technology.

Madeleine S. KillackyMadeleine S. Killacky is a medievalist and specialises in fifteenth-century material culture and the history of the book. She is also researching the intersection of literature and STEM.

Simon PotterSimon Potter is Professor of Modern History at the University of Bristol and author of a number of books on British and global media history, including ‘This is the BBC: Entertaining the Nation, Speaking for Britain? 1922-2022’ (Oxford University Press, 2022) and ‘Wireless Internationalism and Distant Listening: Britain, Propaganda, and the Invention of Global Radio, 1920-1939’ (Oxford University Press, 2021). He is co-author of ‘The Wireless World: Global Histories of International Radio Broadcasting’ (Oxford University Press, 2022).

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of The Political Anthropologist.